Thursday, September 13, 2012

Binge Eating Help!

Hi, Laurie!  I'm 32, 5'4, and 172 lbs.  I'd like to lose a minimum of 30 lbs to get to a healthy weight.  I walk 5 miles a day Monday-Friday and am slowly losing weight.  However, I can't stop binge eating.  I eat a sensible breakfast in the morning and then 20 minutes later, I eat again.  I consume 1,000+ calories and then feel guilty and full all day until dinner.  I feel like I'm sabotaging myself.  I've tried to stop, think, drink water, but I still just can't stop eating!   I feel like I'm stuck on a binge/starve/guilt cycle!  Any advice?   Sheila R.

Dear Sheila,

First of all, congratulations on taking the steps towards a healthier lifestyle that will get you to a healthier weight. Keeping up with the walking is a big commitment and you should be proud!

Now, regarding the binge eating: I could ask you all sorts of questions about that behavior:
- Have you had a major life change recently?
- Is this binge eating brand new for you?
- Are you getting enough sleep?

But all good intentions aside, the way you've described what's going on sounds characteristic of disordered eating. I don't want to alarm you, and I certainly cannot diagnose an eating disorder. 

My guess is, though, that your mind is so crowded with "what can I eat/when can I eat/I shouldn't have that/I can't resist it/ I shouldn't have eaten that/ I feel so awful/ I've failed today/ I'll start again tomorrow" that you aren't able to experience your life and all the pleasures you should be able to enjoy.

If that sounds familiar, rest assured, you are not alone! The National Eating Disorders Association estimates millions of Americans suffer from some type of eating disorder, including binge eating disorder.

The good news is there are kind and understanding counselors who deal specifically with eating disorders (including anorexia, bulimia, orthorexia, and binge eating disorder--also called BED). Counselors who treat people suffering with obsessive thoughts about food, eating, and diet really know what you are going through and can help.

The experts at NEDA can help you find someone in your area who can address this behavior and help you get back to a normal and happy life! Click on the NEDA link above and call to get started right now.
And do write back to let me know how you are doing.


Friday, September 7, 2012

Can You Live on a Liquid Diet?

Hi,
My question is, can someone live their whole life on a liquid diet?
Amanda K.

Yes, Amanda, it is quite possible and many people require liquid diets for periods of time that may span the rest of their life.
I have provided prescribed liquid diets to patients with a broken jaw, for example, who are not going to be able to chew for several weeks. But the diet must include a variety of foods to meet nutritional needs, paying close attention to calorie needs. Merely drinking beverages instead of eating food may result in a diet that is not balanced; for instance, if you drink mostly soda (which has no nutritional value). Even if you drink milk and juice--healthy beverages-- the diet must still be carefully planned to include a balance of essential nutrients.

Many people live on liquid diets because of certain conditions. Examples include diseases that prevent safe swallowing, such as throat cancer or some strokes; a complication of diabetes called gastroparesis which prevents the stomach from emptying normally; people who are respirator dependent in some cases; and those who are in a coma. Formulas like Ensure and Boost (which can be found at your local grocery or drug store) are provided in amounts to meet 100% of the daily requirements for the nutrients we know are essential; even fiber is provided in some formulas. And many formulas are adapted for other conditions the person may have, such as diabetes, kidney failure, or high protein needs.

The bottom line is, a nutritious and well-balanced diet can be provided in liquid form and someone can live with that for many years. Just drinking whatever you feel like, however, can easily lead to lack of essential 
nutrients.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Are Artificial Vitamins Harmful to Me or My Children?


Hi,
I was recently researching whether or not 1% fat or skim milk is a healthier alternative compared to whole milk. I read that since all the fat is stripped away, the vitamins have to be "replaced" by synthetic ones and in time, could actually harm the body more than the high-fat whole milk. 

There is SO many different answers/information online that I just do not know what to believe, although I DO want to eat and drink what is best for me. (and my 3 children) Any of your educational input would be GREAT!
Christina P.

Hi Christina,

Low-fat or fat-free milk is better than whole milk for some people because it is lower in fat and cholesterol. If your children are young and active, whole milk may still be appropriate for them.

Vitamins A and D are fat-soluble so the vitamins naturally present in milk are in the fat; therefore, fat-free milk has only trace amounts of vitamin A, and no Vitamin D.

It's quite difficult to find milk that is not fortified with these vitamins; particularly vitamin D. In the first half of the 20th century, when rickets--the deficiency disease of vitamin D--was found rampant, especially in areas of the country where children rarely had exposure to the sun, healthcare providers recommended supplementing milk with vitamin D, since that was a food consumed by almost every child. It was a good way to assure most of the children in the US would get the vitamin D they needed, and the incidence of rickets has been quite low ever since.

There are brands of milk that do not fortify with vitamins and you are more likely to find these in health food stores or organic aisles. But I don't know of any harm that would come to humans from consuming added vitamins as opposed to those naturally found in foods (other than toxicity from excess ingestion). The chemical composition of vitamins in pill form is identical to vitamins occurring in nature.

When you're looking for accurate information, look for agencies that have no obvious conflict of interest (eg, the dairy council will certainly tell you how great milk is, while PETA will have a host of reasons why milk/meat is not healthy). Look to the NIH (National Institute of Health), FDA, USDA (including myplate.gov), the American Heart Association, American Cancer Society, MedlinePlus, or CDC (Centers for Disease Control). 

Monday, September 3, 2012

Can Spray Butter Help Me Lose Weight?

Hi, I was wondering about these spray butters... is there something in them that helps you lose weight? How much would I have to use to start seeing results? And the same question for spray salad dressings also.
Raymond F.

Hello Raymond,
The spray form of butter and salad dressing save calories not just by changing their formula, but by changing their method of application. You end up using less since the spray can cover more area using less of the fat.

A couple of examples:
Salad Dressings
-Wishbone spritzers variety salad dressings provide 15 calories in 10 sprays. That is enough to wet a good portion of a small salad. Even if you usually pour a "light" raspberry vinaigrette over your salad, that's 80 calories in two tablespoons. This is what they call a serving, but try measuring two tablespoons some time, then put it on your salad. Does this cover enough lettuce, tomato, and cucumber for you to be satisfied? If not, you might be using two, three, or even more 'servings' when you dress your salad! If you use regular dressing, something like Creamy Caesar dressing contains 170 calories in the same two tablespoons: Measure how much you use on your next salad to figure out how many calories you'll be saving by switching to the spray method.
You don't have to buy this particular brand. You could actually use any light dressing, put it in a spray bottle and use less dressing.


Butters and Spreads 
-On your toast, corn cob, or in a fry pan, a tablespoon of regular stick butter provides 100 calories. Spreads that come in a squeeze bottle (the more liquid, the lower in saturated fat) provide about 60 calories per tablespoon. Whipped butter comes in lower at only 50 calories per tablespoon. But the lowest of all is the "I can't believe it's not butter" spray with less than one calorie in five sprays. Now, it may take you 20 or 30 sprays to cover your entire bagel in the morning, but that's still fewer than 10 calories.

Imagine how many calories you consume by covering your food with fats like butter and salad dressing; think about how many you can save by switching to the sprays.

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

I Need Some Good and Healthy Snack Ideas.

Hi Laurie,
Now that it's back to school for the kids (and back to work for lots of us, too) I find myself getting frustrated trying to plan healthy snacks for the whole family. I like to keep some in my desk at work, send my husband to his job with something healthy to tide him over, and have things at home for the kids (10, 12 and 15) that are at least somewhat good for us and not too many calories.
I know fruit is a good idea, but that does get boring after a while. And it seems like fruit or 100-calorie snack bags are not enough to last until dinner at 6:30 pm lots of times.
Are there any snacks that are good for you and filling?
Thanks, Brenda R.

Hi Brenda,
Snacks are definitely a fact of life! While snacking too frequently or on foods too high in fat and calories is not helpful, many people depend on snacks to supplement calories, protein and nutrients in their diet that they might not get during their three daily meals. What the best snack is for you and your family members depends largely on what else they eat during the day, as well as how active they are.

For active young people, snacks can supply necessary nutrients for growth and activities.

For the person who has a physically demanding job (or workout) snacks can (and should) be higher in calories.
And for the sedentary worker or dieter trying to lose weight, snacks can provide fiber, vitamins and minerals in few calories, while tiding you over until the next meal.

Here are some considerations to guide better choices for each individual:

1) Do you want a high-calorie (more than 200) or low-calorie (less than 200) choice? For high-calorie choices think more along the line of a mini-meal than a fattening treat: A peanut butter sandwich and a glass of milk, for example, provides as many calories as a cinnamon roll, but with a lot more nutrition. Think about protein foods to get more calories at the same time as more nutrition: cheese and crackers, deviled eggs, nuts, even prepared items--like protein bars or Carnation Instant Breakfast--can help meet daily protein needs and tide you over until dinner time. Low-calorie snacks can still supply protein, but think lower fat and carb: a turkey wrap, cottage cheese and fruit, or a granola bar can be filling snacks without additional empty calories.

2) Do you want to eat it fast or take your time nibbling? If your purpose is to get some nutrition in before heading to the gym, you don't want to fill up or eat a very high-fiber snack. Some of the protein bars are ideal for this purpose. If you are fighting boredom, eating at your desk (which is basically not a good idea!), and trying not to consume too many calories, consider a snack of carrot sticks or celery for plenty of munching: Add hummus or salsa--both low in calories--for texture and flavor. A cup of dry cereal can also satisfy the munchies without too many calories and often with a healthy dose of vitamins. Don't forget about beverages! Sometimes we think we crave food when we are actually experiencing thirst. If you worry about diet soda or other artificially sweetened beverages, find alternative ways to flavor water, like with a splash of fruit juice or a flavored tea bag. Skip the regular soda and sweetened tea at all costs--they are purely empty calories!

3) What nutrients are you missing during the rest of your day? Snacks can be a good time to get in a serving of calcium, fiber, vitamins and minerals. Think low-fat yogurt, a high-fiber cereal with fat-free milk, fresh fruits and veggies, low-fat cheeses (like babybel) or nuts. 

4) Do you have room for 'treats' in your diet? Guidelines suggest no more than 10% of your calories should come from "treat" foods. This means 200 calories of "junk food" are alloted for a 2000 calorie diet, which is one serving a day, tops! Cookies and chips are alright some of the time, but use common sense for these extras: Keep calories low with low-fat muffins, baked chips, and pre-portioned servings (either 100-calorie snack bags, or snacks you portion out at home ahead of time to prevent over-indulging). If you're planning on a glass of wine or dessert after dinner, go with something nutrient-dense and low-calorie in the afternoon. You'll be glad you did the next time you step on the scale!

For a lot more information about snacks, including a list of 50 ideas, view the "smart snacking" ebook (in the Choose to Lose section) on my products page. Choose any other product and get the Smart Snack e book for free through September 30, 2012!


Tuesday, August 28, 2012

The Doctor Won't Order Intravenous Nutrition

Hello, I have a concern I hope you can help me with. My mother, who has always been in good health, is now in her 80s and has started to have her health fail. She is in the hospital for work-up, finally, but suffers from a very poor appetite and weight loss. It seems she won't be able to fight whatever is wrong without building up her strength. We have asked the doctor to start intravenous nutrition (they call it TPN) but he refuses. He says he can have a tube put into her stomach to feed her, but we feel this is quite invasive. What do you make of the situation?
Kevin T.

Hello Kevin,

I'm sorry to hear your mother is ill. I have seen cases just like this over the many years I've worked in hospitals as a clinical dietitian to help patients become as well-nourished as possible. Your doctor is, in my opinion, giving you the best and safest option. 

While a tube into the stomach may seem invasive (whether it is threaded through the nose, or through a small opening made in the skin near the stomach), it maintains the body's usual form of receiving nutrition. Nutrients go directly into the digestive system. There are very few risks with these tubes. Perhaps the most serious is aspiration, where the formula can regurgitate and end up going into the lungs. (This happens most often in unresponsive patients who cannot sit up and may not have their normal swallow reflex).

Intravenous (or Total Parenteral Nutrition) feeding consists of making an opening into a large vein and delivering concentrated sources of nutrients that do not require digestion. The side effects of this procedure are numerous: Complications during the surgery can be serious; once the line is in place it's an opportunity for infection, and bacteria entering into the blood stream has quite severe consequences; nutrient delivery does not go through the usual route and causes some abnormalities in liver function; high blood sugars are common, and triglycerides can rise in the blood to potentially hazardous levels; over-feeding can occur and it can be difficult to maintain normal mineral and electrolyte levels while on TPN. And finally, not using the gastrointestinal tract leads to atrophy of the cells in the intestine, which are actually an important part of the body's immune system.
The only reason TPN should be used is when the GI tract cannot be used (severe vomiting or diarrhea, blockage, or removal of part of the intestine prohibiting feeding into the gut).


In cases such as your mothers, the dietitian should be called in to consult, and steps taken to work from least to most invasive. First, your mother should be offered foods she likes; secondly she should be offered snacks or smaller meals so she has more chance of taking in enough nutrition if her appetite is small; third is the offering of nutritional supplements like Ensure or Boost, which can provide hundreds of calories with mere sips of the drink taken all day long; another option is prescription appetite stimulants which work very well in some patient populations. Finally, once the source of her illness is discovered, working to treat that may cause her appetite to return.

Tube feedings are one of the last options (largely because the patient is not often willing to have one placed) but are an extremely important weapon in combating malnutrition. Low body weight, low blood protein levels, and minimal nutritional intake may call for this intervention. And better sooner than later.
TPN is THE last option and should not be considered unless there are no other options to nourish your mother, or any other patient.

I hope your mother feels better soon. If you don't see her poor intake being aggressively addressed, ask for the dietitian to be consulted and keep in touch with her about your mother's plan of care.

Friday, August 24, 2012

My Personal Trainer Recommends a High Protein Diet; What Do You Think?

Hi,
I recently purchased an online program with a trainer guiding me for 12 weeks. I just wanted to get the independent opinion of a dietitian on the diet I am following and the results I'm looking to achieve. 
A bit about me: I am 34 years old, 5'6" and 112#. I have lost 5 pounds so far on this program in 4 weeks. I do 45 min of cardio 3 x a week, 35 min of interval cardio 3 x a week, and 45 min of weights followed by 20 min of cardio  3 x a week.
I eat 1200-1500 calories a day divided as follows: 125 gm protein, 50 gm carbs, 35 gm fat.
My goal is to get my body fat from 18 percent down to 14 percent. I want to be toned and not just thin.
Does this sound like a good plan to you?
Thanks, Renee L.

Hi Renee,

To be honest, there are a few things I find concerning about your program:

1 - You were already a bit below "ideal" body weight for your height, and at the low end of "average" body fat for women as well.  I think it's fine to prefer a toned physique, but I'm not sure why your trainer has advised a weight-loss regimen (or gone along with your request for one).


2 - You don't mention whether or not you're an athlete. I might assume you are, based on the amount of exercise you're doing and also based on your initial weight. It sounds like you're probably exercising every day, and more than one time a day on some days (since there are 9 periods of exercise in the program). It sounds a little much for a typical woman's schedule (keeping in mind I deal mostly with overweight people who rarely exercise--but still it seems more than usual to me). 
I wonder if there is any preoccupation on your part with exercise and weight loss or some elements of an eating disorder or body image disorder involved. I don't mean to be an alarmist, but I'd like you to ask yourself: Do you focus on your body, your weight, your diet and your exercise to an extent you feel is excessive? To the exclusion of other activities? (Would you skip a friend's bridal shower or turn down an invitation to go to a vacation destination because it would mean missing work-outs and having to deal with 'forbidden' food offerings?)

3 - The macronutrient breakdown you've shown me adds up to just over 1000 calories; not anywhere near 1200-1500.  These and other details bring me to my most important question:

4 - What kind of licensure, certification or training does this person have who you've hired? There is a reason for laws against people without proper training and licensing practicing nutrition. It's because there are cases in which it can truly be harmful to follow certain regimens. For example, you are consuming more than 1 gram of protein per pound body weight. In people with kidney failure the protein intake must be limited to about 1/3 of this level. 
If you were my client I, as a registered dietitian, would have conducted a thorough medical interview before working with you. Did this person ask you any medical questions or ask to see any of your blood work from a family physician? Did they inquire as to your weight history, medical history or any medications you are taking? (If a person with diabetes suddenly dropped their carbohydrate intake to a level like you are following they could go into insulin shock  from their usual insulin dose and this can be fatal).

Chances are you aren't going to suffer any long-term ill effects from this regimen. But you are right to question the validity and sensibility of the program. I would question the person giving you advice to put my mind at ease about the regimen that has been suggested for you.